Eggnog Sugar Cookies

Cake-like sugar cookies iced with spiced eggnog buttercream!

Cake like sugar cookies with spiced eggnog buttercream. Nothing says “happy holidays” quite like screeching violins.  My 4th grader’s orchestra had a holiday extravaganza.  It was her first time playing in front of a live audience.  Actually, that’s not true, her family has been her live audience for quite some time.  It’s always so sweet to see how excited all the students are to be performing.  You know in their minds they sound like the London Philharmonic.  While the audience is grinning like fools trying to pretend that we are enraptured by the melodies accosting our tender ears.  I suspect there were quite a few earplugs among the audience members. Eggnog Sugar Cookies   I wanted to play the violin when I was my daughter’s age.  But my parents weren’t keen on the price.  So I played the recorder instead (which was free).  Who decided that 4th graders should be trusteed with high pitched, plastic wind instruments???  They must have had an evil streak, because no one in their right mind would unleash that kind of noise on their worst enemies!   Looking back, I am sort of amazed that my parents tolerated my recorder playing.  I use the term “playing” quite loosely.   I don’t recall them complaining about my recorder playing once.  They just quietly disappeared from the room. Eggnog Sugar Cookies How did we celebrate the big performance??? With cookies of course!  Since eggnog only comes around once a year, I figured I had to use it in my cookie frosting!   These sugar cookies are not overly sweet, which makes them the perfect vehicles for the nutmeg flavored buttercream! Eggnog Sugar Cookies   It’s been three days since my daughter’s performance.  She can’t stop playing the violin.  And I can’t stop eating these sugar cookies!  The more she plays, the more I eat…I’ve got to stop her.


White Chocolate Peppermint Sugar Cookie Pizza Pic 1

White Chocolate Peppermint Sugar Cookie Pizza

Apple Cinnamon Sugar Cookie Bars

Apple Cinnamon Sugar Cookie Bars




Eggnog Sugar Cookies
Prep time
Total time
Serves: 72
  • 1 ½ cups butter, softened
  • 2 cups sugar
  • 4 eggs
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla
  • 5 cups flour
  • 2 teaspoons baking powder
  • 1 teaspoon salt
  • ½ cup butter, softened
  • ½ cup shortening
  • 7 cups powdered sugar
  • pinch of salt
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla
  • ¼ cup refrigerated eggnog
  1. In a large bowl, combine butter and sugar. Beat until fluffy. Mix in eggs and vanilla. Slowly mix in flour, baking powder and salt. Batter will be very thick. Cover and refrigerate for at least one hour, or overnight.
  2. Pre heat oven to 400. Sprinkle your work surface with flour and working with one portion of the dough at time, roll out sugar cookie dough to ½ inch thick. Cut with shaped cookies. Place cookies on ungreased baking sheets. Bake for 6-8 minutes or until bottoms just begin brown. Remove to cooling racks to cool completely before frosting.
  3. For the frosting: cream together butter and shortening. Slowly beat in powdered sugar one cup at a time. Blend in salt and vanilla. Add eggnog and continue to beat buttercream until it is spreading consistency, adding more eggnog if necessary.
Recipe Adapted from All Recipes


Follow Tanya Schroeder’s board Holly Jolly on Pinterest.

I may be linking this up to these parties and to

21 Responses

    • Thank you Julie, I hope you get to try them.

  1. huntfortheverybest

    love the frosting!

  2. I used to have a recorder. Then when I was in middle school I played the Clarinet for like a month. I hated it so I switched to the flute. I think I did that for two years. But I didn’t stick with it when I went to high school.

    Great cookies, Tanya! Thanks for sharing at Marvelous Mondays. Have a great weekend!

    • I always wanted to play the flute too Julie! I wish I still had these Eggnog Cookies to munch on! Thanks Julie!

  3. […] going to push for people to enjoy seasonal flavors all year round.  I’m going to munch on eggnog sugar cookies in May and cool down with Eggnog Smoothies in August.  In June, I’m going to decorate […]

  4. Megan

    I am not sure I will be able to find eggnog this year, but these sound fabulous. Is there a substitute for the actual eggnog (maybe a creamy liquid with the spices) that you would recommend? I may break down and make my own eggnog if I cannot find it here in Ibiza, but not sure how that will turn out either. 😀 Thanks!

    • Megan, you could use milk and add nutmeg for your frosting. Although you may not have eggnog flavored coffee creamer, another flavor would work well.

  5. […] get to the zoo.  It would still have meaning if we didn’t make batches and batches of eggnog cookies and peppermint bark fudge and Santa would still come if we didn’t have all the decorations up […]


Add your Response

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Rate this recipe: