Buckeye Cupcakes #OXOGoodCupcake

Rich chocolate cupcakes filled and then topped with creamy peanut butter frosting!

A taste reminiscent of Buckeye Candies!

Chocolate cupcakes filled and frosted with the best peanut butter frosting!  www.lemonsforlulu.com

Kids are funny aren’t they?  They always think they are pulling the wool over your eyes, but in reality they are as transparent as Suran wrap!  Maybe that’s just my own kids.  When will they realize that 1. I hear, see and smell everything.  2.  I have supernatural intuition.  3.  I know everything.  On numerous occasions I have caught my kids in the act of being completely mischievous.  Upon discovering that the “gig is up” each kid will shout “I didn’t do it!”.  Never fails.  And I will glance upon each sweet little face and be able to discern exactly what happened without a word being spoken.  In their innocence, they don’t realize that I know them as well as I know myself.  I know their personalities, their tendencies, their strengths and weaknesses.  I can tell instantly who is lying by their expressions and their tone of voice.  Every mother knows these things.  It’s our JOB!  I know without a doubt that my oldest daughter is the mastermind behind every single plot and ploy.  I know without a doubt that my son will always do what she says because after 8 years he is simply used to following her lead.  And I know for certain that my youngest will also follow because she looks up to both of them!  That’s the way it has always been and that’s probably the way it will be for some time.

Like Buckeye balls?  Then these cupcakes are for you!  Chocolate cupcakes filled and frosted with creamy peanut butter frosting.  www.lemonsforlulu.com

My oldest is the sneakiest of the bunch.  You have to watch her like a hawk.  Which I do.  Because as I said, I have supernatural senses and I know everything.  I KNOW everything because I was once that sneaky little kid.  This latter fact escapes my daughter completely.  Kids forget that you were once a kid just like them.  In all the years of their existences we’ve simply been parents and therefore must have never had any fun.  My daughter’s biggest crime is sneaking candy.  I know if I have an opened bag of any sort of candy that wasn’t used up in my baking, she will quietly and systematically eat every last piece regardless of how many times I’ve told her to stay clear of my stash.   And if her siblings aren’t eating their Halloween, Easter, Valentine, Christmas or whatever the occasion candy quick enough, she will surely finish the job.

Chocolate and peanut butter cupcakes modeled after Buckeye ball!  www.lemonsforlulu.comMy oldest just turned 10 last week.  She wanted Buckeye balls and cupcakes for her birthday and because I have an extreme love for peanut butter and chocolate, I eagerly obliged!  Naturally after the buckeyes were made, my daughter asked if she could try one.  I agreed, but only to her sampling one piece of candy.  After she’d been missing for several minutes I realized what was going on.  I knew that I was going to find my daughter by the buckeye’s with a ring of chocolate around her lips.  And I knew that when I asked her if she had more than one, that she will admit to eating several.  I know this because that is exactly what I would have done!  As the saying goes, the apple does not fall far from the tree!

Chocolate cupcakes with a healthy swirl of peanut butter frosting inside and on top!  www.lemonsforlulu.com

I made these cupcakes as part of #BakeaDifference with OXO and Cookies for Kids’ Cancer.  I am honored to have been selected by Oxo to participate in this program.  Not only did I receive the perfect tools to make these cupcakes, but Oxo will donate $100 for each post written!

Cookies for Kids’ Cancer was founded by a couple of OXO employees after their 2 year old son battled cancer.   OXO has been matching the proceeds of bake sales, and this year is committing up to $100,000 to fight pediatric cancer.

Wanna help?  There are lots of ideas on the OXO Good Cookies  website, including hosting a bake sale of your own and  donating the proceeds and OXO will match your donation.  Buy some cookies, and 100% of the proceeds will be donated.  Or, purchase their specially-marked OXO baking tools, and Oxo will donate 25 cents to Cookies for Kids’ Cancer.  Come join the fight!


Peanut Butter In The Middle

Buckeye Cookie Bites www.lemonsforlulu.com

Buckeye Cookie Bites


Caramel Peanut Butter Cups www.lemonsforlulu.com

Caramel Peanut Butter Cups





Buckeye Cupcakes #OXOGoodCupcake
For the Cupcake
  • ½ cup cocoa powder
  • ⅔ cup boiling water
  • ⅔ cup bittersweet chocolate, chopped
  • 1 ½ sticks softened butter
  • 1 ½ cups sugar
  • 4 whole eggs
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla
  • 2 cups flour
  • 1 teaspoon baking soda
  • ¼ teaspoon salt
  • 1 cup plain Greek yogurt
For the Frosting
  • ½ cup butter
  • 1 ¼ cup creamy peanut butter
  • 4 cup powdered sugar
  • ½ cup cream
  1. Preheat oven to 350. Line two cupcake pans and set aside.
  2. Place cocoa in a bowl. Pour boiling water over cocoa and whisk until smooth. Add chopped chocolate and stir until melted. Set aside.
  3. In a mixer, beat butter and sugar on medium speed until creamy. Add eggs one at a time beating well after each addition. Mix in vanilla.
  4. Combine flour, baking soda and salt in a separate bowl. Slowly add dry ingredients to wet in two additions, adding the yogurt in between each addition. Mix just until incorporated. Stir in your chocolate.
  5. Fill liners ⅓ full. Bake for 20 minutes or until a toothpick inserted in the center comes out clean. Let cupcakes cool in pan.
  6. Prepare the frosting. In a mixer bowl, combine butter and peanut butter beating until smooth. Very slowly mix in powdered sugar, one cup at a time mixing well after each addition. Add in cream and beat until frosting is piping consistency, adding more cream if necessary.
  7. To assemble: cut out a small hole into the center of each cupcake using a pairing knife or an
  8. Oxo cupcake corer. Pipe frosting into center of each cupcake. Then pipe your frosting using an 844 large tip onto each cupcake.



I’ll be linking this recipe up these parties as well as to:

You may also like:

Roasted Banana Cupcakes with Peanut Butter Ganache Frosting        Chocolate Moosey

White Chocolate Cupcakes with Peanut Butter Frosting                         Shugary Sweets

Reeses Peanut Butter Filled Chocolate Cupcakes                                       Chasing Delicious

39 Responses

  1. My kids can be just as sneaky and they never figure out how mommy just knows!!! These look amazing and I think it is great what OXO is doing with this campaign!!

  2. Oh shoot… this is serious trouble for me! I’m in LOVE with peanut butter and chocolate everything, especially buckeyes! Wow thank you so much :)

    • Thanks Abbe! I love buckeyes way too much!

  3. Tanya these cupcakes look heavenly! Pinning for my next cupcake baking day!

  4. I wonder if my mom knew what I was up to when I was kid? Although I wasn’t bad, I wasn’t exactly innocent either (and blamed my brother lol) Love buckeyes and how you cut out the center to insert even more frosting. And thanks for linking to my cupcakes!

    • Ha, glad I wasn’t the only sneaky one! Thanks Carla!

  5. What a fantastic idea for cupcakes! So simple!!

  6. Kids are definitely sneaky, aren’t they? Or at least they try to be. If my 2-year-old wants to do something he’s not allowed to do, he asks me, “Mommy, can you go out of here?” Um, definitely not now!

    I keep seeing Buckeye recipes and didn’t realize that was a kind of candy. I don’t think I’ve ever had one, but I’m definitely in favor of anything peanut butter and chocolate! These cupcakes look out of this world, and thank you for writing for such a great cause. Have a nice weekend, Tanya!

    • I guess if you aren’t from the mid west, you may not know abut buckeyes. I usually make them at Christmas time, they are such a treat!

  7. juliemurkerson

    Oh yea, chocolate and peanut butter is a HUGE win for me! I love these cupcakes, Tanya! I’ll be right there to get one. 😉 Pinned!

    • Huge for me too Julie! Thanks for pinning!

  8. Oh my! I would totally gobble these up!! LOVE buckeyes and they look possibly even better in cupcake form! My oldest is totally a candy thief, too….and I was the exact same way! It’s always the oldest that’s JUST like their mother :)

    • Hahaha, I do see lots of similarities between me and my oldest! Thanks Cathy!

  9. These look so yummy! :) I do miss living in Columbus just for the ample availability of Buckeye candies EVERYWHERE. These cupcakes look just as yummy though! 😉

    • I am crazy over buckeyes! I could probably eat my weight in them! Thanks Carrie!

  10. These look like one of those recipe that I would make and then eat all of! I think that I might have to stay clear but they look amazing. I guess if we are having a party and someone else might eat some then I might make them but choc and PB is my weakness. They look amazing!!! I started following on G+ so I won’t miss anything :)

    • Chocolate and peanut butter are my weakness as well! I had to give these away so I wouldn’t eat the all!

  11. I told my kids that I was psychic when they were growing up. :) It still drives my son crazy when I figure out what he is going to say, before he says it. When he went somewhere with his friends without telling me, I always magically found out. See….I’m psychic…so don’t try anything….I will always know! 😉 Those look delicious Tanya, and such a great cause!

  12. Oh my goodness, I have one of those sneaky candy bandits too! I have to watch my 9-year old like a hawk too! These cupcakes look to-die-for. Obviously pinning! Can’t wait to try! I’ve never made anything Buckeye before!

    • I’m glad I’m not the only one with sneaky kids! Buckeyes are soooo good! Thanks Jen!

  13. […] we muddle through the week.  My oldest sneaks her desserts from my baking stash (read more on this here), my son is fine with granola bars and cereal, my youngest could live on fruit snacks and my […]

  14. Oh I love buckeyes. Peanut butter + Chocolate is just the best combo.

  15. These look so delicious. I love anything peanut butter and chocolate flavored, so these cupcakes look right up my alley :)

    • Thank you Rachel, I do believe chocolate and peanut butter is the bests combo ever!

  16. Samantha

    Is the cream in the frosting heavy whipping cream or just regular milk? These look soooo good I want to make sure I make them just right 😉

  17. […]  I have always made good nutrion for my family a priority.  While I certainly indulge my kids in cupcakes and cookies, laying a strong foundation for my kids that includes a love for fruits, vegetables and […]

  18. […] way.  It’s not as though I don’t like cheesecake, I just prefer desserts with frosting like cupcakes or cake, but I’ll certainly settle for anything with crumbs like brownies or cookies.  You see […]


Add your Response

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Rate this recipe: