• Kitchen Tips
  • Breakfast
  • Savory
  • Sweets
  • Snackies

LemonsforLulu.com

  • Kitchen Tips
  • Breakfast
  • Savory
  • Sweets
  • Snackies
Home » Savory » Pork

His Pork Chops Stayed Tough After a 15 Hour Brine, and Reddit Said the Brine Wasn’t the First Thing to Fix

October 4, 2026 by LemonsForLulu Editors · Pork
Add LemonsForLulu to Google Preferred Sources

A home cook tried to rescue dry, tough boneless pork chops with a 15 hour dry brine of salt, brown sugar, and seasonings. The next batch came out much juicier, but the meat was still tough. He wondered whether a wet brine, a longer dry brine, bone in chops, or better pork would solve the problem. Reddit cooks kept coming back to something else: stop relying on cooking time and watch the internal temperature.

The chops were about 1 inch thick. After brining, he seared them for three minutes per side, then put them into a 400°F oven for about 10 minutes.

Reddit kept asking about temperature

Several commenters focused on the thermometer before debating wet versus dry brining.

One advised checking internal temperature instead of relying on a fixed number of minutes because chop thickness, starting temperature, pans, and ovens can change the result.

Another put the rule in four words: “Cook to temperature, not time.”

The original poster already owned an instant read thermometer but said its guidance listed 160°F for medium. Several commenters considered that too high for the result he wanted.

  • Stop Washing These 5 Foods Before Cooking Them
  • She Dipped Mini Pretzels in Orange Chocolate and Turned Them Into Tiny Pumpkins

Brining can help, but longer isn’t always better

The cook noticed a clear improvement after dry brining. His second chop was much juicier, even though toughness remained.

That doesn’t mean another 10 hours in salt is the automatic next step.

Advice in the thread varied. Some preferred short brines, while others dry brined for 12 to 24 hours. One commenter warned that extended brining of smaller cuts can change the texture and make the finished meat too salty.

Another recommended measuring salt against the weight of the pork rather than adding an arbitrary amount.

Wet and dry brines give different results

Several cooks in the thread preferred wet brines for pork chops. One described using a molasses brine, while another recommended a salt solution with seasonings.

Other commenters preferred dry brining because the drier exterior can produce a better sear and avoid diluting the pork flavor.

There wasn’t one answer shared by everyone. The stronger point across the discussion was that changing the brine won’t compensate for poor temperature control.

A lower oven can give you more control

One commenter suggested reversing the order.

Instead of hard searing first and following with a 400°F oven, cook thick chops in a 200°F to 250°F oven, watch their internal temperature, then finish them in a hot skillet for one or two minutes per side.

Another recommended the same reverse sear approach for thick chops, using a low oven followed by a short, hot sear.

Bone in wasn’t the clear answer either

The poster also wondered whether buying bone in chops would solve the toughness problem.

Reddit disagreed. One commenter felt bone in chops were juicier and more tender, while another said the bone itself does nothing for tenderness.

Cut quality and thickness came up too. One cook recommended buying better pork and choosing thicker chops when using a reverse sear.

The original poster ended the discussion planning to try a wet brine next. But the thread left him with another variable to watch before changing the brine again: the thermometer.

Related Reading

Poached Salmon in Red Vermouth and Garlic The World’s Most Expensive Cheese Jalapeno Chicken Grilled Cheese with White BBQ Sauce Instant Pot Beef Stroganoff Slow Cooker Oxtail Stew Shrimp Po Boy Recipe with Cilantro Pesto Slaw

Filed Under: Pork

Stop Washing These 5 Foods Before Cooking Them
Don’t Freeze Blackberries Straight in the Bag, Do This First

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Reading

Poached Salmon in Red Vermouth and Garlic The World’s Most Expensive Cheese Jalapeno Chicken Grilled Cheese with White BBQ Sauce Instant Pot Beef Stroganoff Slow Cooker Oxtail Stew Shrimp Po Boy Recipe with Cilantro Pesto Slaw
Lemons for Lulu has the recipes that are destined to become your new family favorites -- big on flavor but easy to prepare!

Sign up for our weekly newsletters!

Ready to cook?

About Contact Terms and Conditions Privacy Policy Disclosure Policy

Copyright ©2026, LemonsforLulu.com. All Rights Reserved.