• Kitchen Tips
  • Breakfast
  • Savory
  • Sweets
  • Snackies

LemonsforLulu.com

  • Kitchen Tips
  • Breakfast
  • Savory
  • Sweets
  • Snackies
Home » cake, dessert

Grandma Made Up to Seven Kinds of Pie for Thanksgiving, but Her Granddaughter-in-Law Brought a Cake for a Reason

November 22, 2026 by LemonsForLulu Editors · cake, dessert
Add LemonsForLulu to Google Preferred Sources

Thanksgiving dessert was Grandma’s territory. Every year, she made five to seven kinds of pie and decided which dishes would appear at the family dinner. But when her granddaughter-in-law asked to bring an elderly friend with no family, Grandma refused.

The guest was a man in his 70s who had no relatives to spend Thanksgiving with. Grandma wanted dinner restricted to family members. Rather than skip the gathering, the woman decided to bring a dessert that wasn’t part of the traditional menu.

Reddit user u/Le-Chat-Blanc shared the story in r/pettyrevenge, explaining why she ordered a bakery cake instead of making another pie.

Grandma Refused to Add Another Guest to Thanksgiving Dinner

The woman asked whether her friend could join the family’s Thanksgiving meal. Grandma’s answer was, “no, let’s just keep it family.”

The refusal upset her because the man had no family to celebrate with. She considered staying home but decided against it.

Instead, she spent the following week thinking about how to respond without confronting Grandma at the dinner table.

  • Your dishwasher has a filter under the bottom rack, and the smell comes back until you pull it out
  • Not vinegar and not a magic eraser, the way to get the brown ring out of a coffee thermos for good

She Bought a Bakery Cake Knowing Grandma Had Made the Pies

Grandma’s Thanksgiving dessert spread was a family tradition, with five to seven varieties of pie each year.

The granddaughter-in-law ordered a cake from a bakery she considered the best in town. She hoped guests would choose it over Grandma’s pies.

When she arrived, family members asked what she had brought and expressed interest in the cake. According to the Reddit author, Grandma stared at it for about 30 seconds without speaking.

The woman considered that reaction enough to make her point.

Grandma Asked to Keep the Last Slice of Cake

The result took another turn when dinner ended. As the woman packed up the leftovers, Grandma asked whether she could keep the last slice.

The author suspected Grandma had heard other guests praising the cake and wanted to taste it.

The Reddit discussion focused less on the dessert and more on the man who had been excluded from dinner.

User u/LMH2710 wrote, “I feel like your friend got forgotten in this revenge…”

The author explained that she had taken him out to dinner the Wednesday before Thanksgiving and made plans to meet again. He had also received a Thanksgiving invitation from a neighbor, although she did not know whether he attended.

Another commenter, u/Sugar-n-Spice, suggested a different way to make the point: “I think I might have had to tell her that I was taking it to my friend since he had no family and I wanted him to have something nice for Thanksgiving.”

The bakery cake remained part of the family’s dessert spread, and Grandma ended the evening wanting a piece of the dessert her granddaughter-in-law had brought to challenge the pie tradition.

Would you bring a cake to a Thanksgiving dinner where the host takes pride in making all the pies?


Story credit: Reddit user u/Le-Chat-Blanc, who shared the account in r/pettyrevenge.

Related Reading

Say goodbye to the kitchen sponge, what cleaning pros use instead and why it never smells Weekly Meal Plan #14 5 Best Baking Soda Substitute Options 14 Best Peanut Butter Substitute Options Slow Cooker Ginger Beef She Adds 2 Teaspoons of Instant Espresso to Chocolate Cheesecake — Here’s What It Does

Filed Under: cake, dessert

Your dishwasher has a filter under the bottom rack, and the smell comes back until you pull it out

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Reading

Say goodbye to the kitchen sponge, what cleaning pros use instead and why it never smells Weekly Meal Plan #14 5 Best Baking Soda Substitute Options 14 Best Peanut Butter Substitute Options Slow Cooker Ginger Beef She Adds 2 Teaspoons of Instant Espresso to Chocolate Cheesecake — Here’s What It Does
Lemons for Lulu has the recipes that are destined to become your new family favorites -- big on flavor but easy to prepare!

Sign up for our weekly newsletters!

Ready to cook?

About Contact Terms and Conditions Privacy Policy Disclosure Policy

Copyright ©2026, LemonsforLulu.com. All Rights Reserved.